The calm before the coming moment
Thomas Homer-Dixon writing in the Globe and Mail this weekend:
Constitutive moments are a special kind of historical inflection point. Powerful actors like U.S. presidents always operate within a constellation of macro-trends, cultures, institutions, and social and political alliances. But during constitutive moments, they have a rare opportunity to radically reconfigure that constellation because the usual constraints on selecting from, combining, and adjusting its elements are greatly weakened. The systems they’re operating within are abnormally susceptible to massive change.
Leaders who effectively exploit these opportunities can create not just profoundly new ways of doing things, but also new ways of seeing things. A constitutive moment shifts our deepest understandings of the world and its possibilities, and to the extent that these understandings partially create the world around us, it shifts our world’s essence itself
I’m coming back from nearly 2 weeks working in the United States and I would be lying if it didn’t feel like it was a little bit like watching the film of people enjoying the last few minutes of their holiday before the tsunami hit Indonesia in 2004. I’m not sure if the foreboding dread I feel for my friends and colleagues in the States is an over-reaction, or whether I’m not taking it seriously enough. I think Homer-Dixon‘s article captures it quite well. It’s a constitutive moment, and what that means remains to be seen, but I’m reading articles about the fragility of Canada and our inability to meet what’s coming without strong and visionary leadership. I’m reading articles and opinions I never imagined would appear in mainstream newspapers. I see that we are at a loss. Mired in the apprentice moment.
The people we’ve been working with over the past two weeks, in academic institutions in Texas, and community organizations, and foundations, and frontline agencies in Alaska, are the best people. They are the folks that will be present for what’s coming. They are the ones who are always extending care, who are putting the best interests of their students and clients and colleagues front and center. I leave them feeling concern and love and admiration for them. Many are scared. Some are ready. Others are welcoming this moment. It’s not simple.
We truly have no idea what is coming. And so I leave this montage of four images which I took on a walk around downtown Seattle on Saturday, and which captured my mood and the feeling of the city on a beautiful cold, perfectly clear, January 18, 2025.
Wow, Chris…. thank you. Just thank you….
Having lived in the US since I was a child, first with a green card, then as a naturalized citizen, I feel deeply connected with what is taking place now in the US… even as I write to you from Germany, where I am currently living on a fellowship…. and which is having its own “constitutive moment”.
Yep, it’s not simple. And though we may know a lot, and have a lot of educated guesses, there is also a great deal of uncertainty, and we really don’t know, what will happen — what will be the outcome of, not just of what the conventionally-powerful actors do, but also, of how we each choose to respond, and what we each choose to create, within the larger context that always influences yet does not determine our possibilities…
thank you.
In the last few years I have unexpectedly and quite organically gotten myself in a position to practice and strengthen community accountability in / among multiple communities, not least the one I live in. Drawing a lot of strength from the fact that there are many around me who are seriously interested in this work, and are ready to learn and share and practice.
We have a lot of work ahead.