I was reading the striking conversation between Jimmy Wales and Dale Hoiberg, from Wikipedia and Encyclopedia Britannica respectively, and I suddenly had the strangest thought.
These two publications represent completely different creations stories.
Britannica is the Garden of Eden, a perfectly designed place that can only get worse as people tamper with it. It is the “order to chaos” model and so it is surrounded with protection to keep it in it’s pristine form.
(I was also surprised to read Mr. Hoiberg’s comment that the Britannica endeavours to represent all of human knowledge. That seems absurd to me.)
Wikipedia is the Ojibway creation story worldview, the one in which the animals help Giizhigokwe make a new world out of some soil and a turtle’s back. In this model we move from chaos to order by inviting as many people as possible to come and contribute, knowing that things can only get better in general.
I hadn’t thought of these two efforts as inhabiting the archetypes of world creation stories before. I probably need to get out more!
[tags]wikipedia, encyclopedia britannica, creation stories, jimmy wales, dale hoiberg[/tags]

